Primis Financial Corp. (NASDAQ:FRST) Q3 2023 Results Conference Call October 27, 2023 10:00 AM ET
Company Participants
Matt Switzer – CFO
Dennis Zember – President and CEO
Conference Call Participants
Casey Whitman – Piper Sandler
Feddie Strickland – Janney Montgomery Scott
Operator
Hello, my name is Krista, and I’ll be your conference operator today. At this time, I would like to welcome everyone to the Primis Financial Corporation Third Quarter Earnings Call. [Operator Instructions] Thank you.
I will now turn the conference over to Matt Switzer, Chief Financial Officer. You may begin.
Matt Switzer
Good morning, and thank you for joining us. Before we begin, please note that many of our comments during this call will be forward-looking statements, which involve risk and uncertainty. There are many factors that could cause actual results to differ materially from the anticipated results or other expectations expressed in the forward-looking statements.
Further discussion of the company’s risk factors and other important information regarding our forward-looking statements are part of our recent filings with the Securities and Exchange Commission, including our recently filed earnings release, which has also been posted to the Investor Relations section of our corporate site, primisbank.com.
We undertake no obligation to update or revise forward-looking statements to reflect changed assumptions, the occurrence of unanticipated events or changes to future operating results over time.
In addition, some of the financial measures that we may discuss this morning are non-GAAP financial measures. A reconciliation of the non-GAAP measures to the most comparable GAAP measures can be found in our earnings release.
I will now turn the call over to our President and Chief Executive Officer, Dennis Zember.
Dennis Zember
Thank you, Matt, and thank you to all of you that have joined our third quarter conference call. I’m excited about our quarter and about the broad-based improvement and momentum we see in some key areas. I’ll discuss a few of those and then give it back to Matt for some more details.
I’m joined today here in the call, by the way, with — by Matt Switzer, who is our CFO; and Rick Fulk, who has recently been named President of Primis Bank.
First and most importantly is our net interest margin. Our margin improved significantly this quarter, thanks to a couple of items. First, we began sweeping excess funds off the balance sheet on June 30. So the entire impact of that was felt in the third quarter, but none of it was felt in the second quarter. If I go back and normalize that for the second quarter, our margin would have still increased in the third quarter by a couple of basis points, which is significant for the margin to be directionally headed that way.
Further, and as our release dates, we had a strong September, with a margin of 3.05%. So we are increasingly confident that we can hold at these levels and continue moving higher.
Obviously, there’s a lot of moving parts at play in improving the margin. But the foundational block to this success are the wins we’re having in the community banking.
On the new account side, we note that we opened 2,404 new accounts for new customers totaling almost $73 million, with a weighted average cost of only $1.80.
On an annualized basis and of course, neutralizing any movements in existing deposit accounts, this would have represented a 9% annualized growth rate in total deposits, and would be almost dead on top of our existing cost of funds. So to have this kind of deposit activity without having to post really high interest rates is pretty notable.
And further, even with the scale of our national deposit platform, we did more than 2/3 of this new account activity in the Community Bank.
On the existing customer side, the core bank managed an impressive 1.91% cost of deposits, which was up only slightly from the second quarter of ’23. The retention of deposits has been a key focus and really more of a challenge, because we announced a consolidation of 8 branches or 25% of our footprint about a quarter ago. But our calling efforts and our customer convenience factors like [Bob] have made such a difference, and the runoff from those 8 branches has been minimal.
In fact, 2 of the 8 branches that we are consolidating actually have increased deposit levels since the announcement. Rick and his team have done an outstanding job with this result, and getting us in a place where we believe it’s sustainable.
Our pipeline for the fourth quarter and closed activity so far looked very promising against our third quarter result, and the energy level and excitement at the bank with these wins is well deserved.
On the digital side, we’ve spent no money on paid marketing in the third quarter. Even so, we opened about 1,400 new accounts, and grew total accounts in the — on the platform by about 15% annualized.
Impressively, the average cost of these new deposits was still below 5%, and a significant percentage of the activity was from existing customer referrals.
In the third quarter, customers opened about 5 new accounts for every one account they closed. Our average balance per customer is $73,000, and our average depositor is about 49 years old.
On the lending side, we’re demonstrating in an increasing fashion, the value of our niches. Between the Community Bank, Panacea and Life Premium, we had new production over $100 million at an average yield of about 7.95%.
Matt noted in the press release that we booked incremental spreads of 5.18% which way more than neutralizes the dilutive pressure of today’s interest rate environment.
Panacea and Life Premium are obviously high-quality lending niches with established brands and sources of business. Both divisions spent the quarter sourcing relationships and partners, whether it be other banks or securitization platforms, and collectively place what I believe is about 25% of their production capacity.
As we go into the fourth quarter, we are going to move this number — this percentage higher and through next year, it’s my hope that we’ll have sources in place to run these engines at full capacity.
Our mortgage division shined this quarter, continues to move forward, albeit in a tough environment to build this kind of division. During the quarter, they funded about $169 million of volume and had pretax earnings of almost $700,000.
Importantly, our division got this excellent result by focusing on top-shelf lenders and serious efforts on cost controls. Our team understands the environment we are in. And when yields turn and volumes jump again and they will do that, our division’s profitability will impress and our disciplines will pay off.
As I close and turn it back to Matt, I want to make a quick comment on the balance sheet itself. Today, we’re sitting here with very strong liquidity and really a great story on deposits. We have strong capital levels. We have very low nonperforming assets. We really have no concentrations in office CRE or really anything problematic. We have substantial loan and deposit engines that are incrementally very profitable, and that we can take on or off the balance sheet.
Our earnings are moving up as well as we inch hire on margins and are able to control and reduce operating expenses. And I really like where we are in this period of uncertainty.
Now with that, I’ll turn it back to you.
Matt Switzer
Thank you, Dennis. I will provide a brief overview of our results before we turn to Q&A. But as a reminder, a full description of our third quarter results can be found in our earnings release and third quarter investor presentation, both of which can be found on our website.
Operating earnings for the third quarter were $7.7 million or $0.32 per diluted share versus $1 million or $0.04 per diluted share in the second quarter, and up over 50% from the year-ago period.
Total assets were $3.8 billion at September 30, flat versus June 30. Excluding PPP loans and loans held for sale, loan balances declined at 1% linked quarter. We sold $15 million of Panacea loans and moved another $9 million to held for sale at September 30. We also sold $10 million of participation in Life Premium finance loans in the quarter. If not for those transactions, loans held for investment would have grown slightly in the third quarter.
Deposits were down slightly in Q3, as we manage excess liquidity by sweeping off excess deposits. We had approximately $229 million of deposits in the sweep program at the end of the quarter.
Impressively, average noninterest-bearing deposits were flat in the third quarter, while ending noninterest-bearing balances increased 2% unannualized from June 30 to September 30.
Our core bank is a source of strength in this environment, and the unique products and services we’ve developed continue to resonate with customers, particularly small businesses.
Net interest income increased $1 million to $27.1 million in the third quarter, as funding cost pressures were offset with higher earning asset yields. Net interest margin increased to 3.02% from 3% last quarter, when adjusting for the excess liquidity we carried in Q2.
We believe we have a unique advantage due to our two-pronged funding strategy. As a result, in the third quarter, we were able to hold the increase in deposit costs in the core bank to 11 basis points, well below the increase in wholesale options.
Excluding accounting adjustments, noninterest income was $7.9 million in the third quarter versus $7.3 million in the second quarter. Mortgage revenue declined slightly in Q3, but was still strong given the environment. Offsetting that decline was an increase in gain on sale income.
We sold $15 million of Panacea loans for a $400,000 gain and moved another $9 million to held for sale as they will close shortly. Additional potential sales in the pipeline lead us to have confidence that gain on sale income will be higher in the fourth quarter.
Core noninterest expense, excluding accounting adjustments, nonrecurring items and mortgage was $20.5 million for the third quarter versus $23.5 million in the previous quarter. The decline is reflective of the administrative cost saves we announced last quarter, and that were effective midway through the third quarter.
We also will consolidate 8 branches at the end of October. We continue to be disciplined on the expense side and look for additional saves through attrition while navigating this challenging environment.
The provision for credit losses was $1.6 million in the third quarter versus $4.3 million last quarter. $2.1 million of the provision was due to accounting for our third-party managed portfolio, and which is offset by noninterest income gains.
Core net charge-offs were $2.3 million, the majority of which was the charge-off of specific reserves tied to the partial resolution of the assisted living problem relationship we have discussed in previous quarters. The final piece of that relationship was resolved in October, bringing pro forma nonperforming assets to $6.5 million or 17 basis points of assets at 9/30.
The allowance for credit losses to gross loans, excluding PPP balances, was 1.14% at September 30 versus 121 basis points last quarter, with the decline largely due to the charge-off of specific reserves and a small reserve release from a lower loan balance and reduced model losses under CECL.
Lastly and in summary, operating ROAA improved to 81 basis points in the third quarter, the highest level since the fourth quarter of ’21. We have further expense savings being realized in the fourth quarter, and are confident we can keep grinding net interest income higher with a healthy margin.
Combined with additional gain on sale revenue, we believe we can still improve profitability even in this difficult environment, and are optimistic about our prospects in the near term.
With that, operator, we can now open the line for Q&A.
Question-and-Answer Session
Operator
[Operator Instructions] Your first question comes from the line of Casey Whitman from Piper Sandler.
Casey Whitman
Congrats on the quarter. So first, can you walk us through how we should think about the size of the balance sheet from here? Do you see that holding pretty flat, allowing profitability improvement, capital accrete? Could we see some modest growth? What is your outlook there?
Matt Switzer
I think we’ll see modest growth over the next 4, 5 quarters, but not nearly the pace it’s been in the last year or 2. So probably mid- to high single digits over that time frame.
Dennis Zember
And really not in a way that moves TCE lower. I mean we want to inch hire on TCE. And I mean, I think we’re more than comfortable with capital levels where they are right now, especially with nonperformers this low. So with earnings moving where they are being able to continue growing the balance sheet, but at a slower pace is what we’re looking for.
Casey Whitman
Okay. So then with some balance sheet growth, the margins stable to maybe even up, like do we have pretty high confidence that we’ve reached the inflection point on NII, and we’ll continue to see growth? Maybe not to the same extent this quarter, but the trend will continue to go up.
Matt Switzer
I think so.
Casey Whitman
Okay. And Dennis, do you want to maybe talk about your success this quarter with the $50 million in deposits at the Community Bank? Can we expect more of this kind of inflow? I just thought that was a big one.
Dennis Zember
Yes. When we announced, well, a month or so before — 45 days or so before we announced the branch closures, Rick and his team sort of mobilized to go out and talk to every customer, that was going to be impacted. And Rick sitting here, Rick, that — not only did that sort of neutralize any impact that you might have seen from closing some branches on the outflows.
I mean, really, they uncovered quite a few opportunities, and it really turned into a little bit more of a sales initiative. And really, there were some — there were a couple of sizable accounts, I think, that we are working on at the end of September that we didn’t — that we didn’t close before quarter end. And I think that’s really why we’re all sitting in here with the confidence about sort of duplicating the third quarter as we go into the fourth quarter.
So and the restructure — I mean it’s important, the restructure that we had in the third quarter — or excuse me, in the second quarter that essentially led us move Rick into this position, and let Rick start directing the team and getting the wins and or building the excitement and energy level there. Pretty positive for our company.
Matt Switzer
And I’ll just add, I mean — and we’re not alone probably with the strategy that we feel like we’re — we’ve got some advantages with some of our technology and products and services. But we are — we have dedicated the core bank 100% to pursue in small business customers.
We can raise retail funds through the digital platform out of market at a reasonable cost. So we don’t have to put a lot of energy into CD specials or other retail deposit raising campaigns in market, because we can do that out of market.
So our focus in the core bank and in our Virginia and Maryland markets is small business, and they’re generally higher balances, lower costs and a lot of them are coming from the big banks, particularly Truist. But also, we’re hearing a lot from P&C that are getting horrible service, as those banks cut back on costs and are still way underpaying on interest rate on those balances. So we think there’s a lot of running room to go after those banks and move some business.
Casey Whitman
Okay. And then can you give us an update as to where you think quarterly expenses will land for the branch consolidations in there? Is it sort of the same range you gave last quarter? Or any change to that?
Matt Switzer
I mean it won’t fully be in until next quarter, but I still feel pretty confident about that range. Maybe it’s much higher. I think we said 18 to 18.5 — maybe 18.5 to 19 at the end of the day, but still comfortable in that neighborhood next quarter.
Casey Whitman
And that just excludes the mortgage, right?
Matt Switzer
Yes, it does. Yes.
Dennis Zember
Branch closed today.
Casey Whitman
Is that right? Is that — the branches closing at the end of the month or today?
Dennis Zember
Today.
Casey Whitman
Okay. Great.
Dennis Zember
All right. Thank you.
Operator
Your next question comes from the line of Feddie Strickland from Janney Montgomery Scott.
Feddie Strickland
I just wanted to go back to that expense point we were just talking about the $18.5 million to $19 million expense run rate. How much could we see that grow over the course of 2024? Just trying to get a good sense for beyond just next quarter or the next couple of quarters, whether that’s low mid-single digits? Or what’s your thinking in terms of expenses for next year?
Matt Switzer
That’s a great question. I mean our — given the environment, we are 100% focused on controlling expenses. So our goal is to bottom out at that level and then keep increases to a minimum. So I’d like to thank low single digits at the end of the day, certainly not higher than that.
Feddie Strickland
Got it. And then I think you mentioned this in your opening comments, but what was the spot rate on new deposits at the end of the quarter, and as we sit here in late October, is that — has that gone up by any meaningful amount?
Dennis Zember
I think the spot rate on deposits, obviously, is still inching higher, not in a dramatic fashion, but what’s — but we’re more than outpacing that with asset repricing and with incremental new business. I mean the incremental new business was solidly in the 5s. So I mean, I think we’re generating enough — honestly, I think we’re generating enough new incremental spread with just new business. That really asset repricing is really what’s moving the margin higher.
Matt Switzer
Yes. I think we saw on cost of deposits in July and August. Overall cost of deposits went up about 5 basis points a month, but it was lower than that in September. And with some of the wins we got late in the month, we’re hoping that’s less than that to flat in October, November.
Feddie Strickland
Understood. That’s helpful. And then the $75 million in brokerage CDs that you have rolling off later this year, do you think you’ll put some level of that back on just the supplement funding base? Or do you feel like deposit growth is strong enough at this point that you can potentially let that roll off?
Matt Switzer
We’re going to let that roll off.
Feddie Strickland
Okay. Last question for me. What’s your base case for net charge-offs over the next couple of quarters? I mean, obviously, we don’t know exactly how everything is going to play out with credit. But should we expect a certain level each quarter and just compare that with where the strong reserve level is today?
Matt Switzer
I think with the last piece of that assisted living relationship, there’s still a little bit of a specific reserve left that will be charged off in the fourth quarter. Absent that, I mean, our charge-off has been running — we’ll have the 600 a quarter — about 600,000 a quarter. And we don’t see any reason why that would be in the near term.
Feddie Strickland
Understood.
Operator
[Operator Instructions] We have no further questions in the queue at this time. I’ll turn the call back over to Dennis Zember for closing remarks.
Dennis Zember
All right. Thank you again for joining our call. I hope you have a good and safe weekend. If you have any questions, we are here in the office, and I’m happy to take the call. All right. Thank you. Have a good day.
Operator
And this concludes today’s conference call. Thank you for your participation, and you may now disconnect.
Read the full article here